Yale study finds calorie labeling doesn’t work

There’s a new study out about calorie labeling and it comes to some interesting conclusions. It’s from the Rudd Center at Yale, authored by Christina Roberto, Peter D. Larsen, Henry Agnew, Jenny Baik, and Kelly D. Brownell. Here’s the basic description of the methodology and conclusion from the Rudd Center’s release:

The researchers studied 303 adults in New Haven, Connecticut, dividing them into three groups – the first saw a menu with no calorie labels, the second saw a menu with calorie labels, and the third saw a menu with calorie labels plus information on the recommended daily caloric intake for an average adult.

Participants in the two groups who saw calorie labels ate 14 percent fewer calories than the group whose participants did not see calorie labels. Furthermore, when after-dinner eating was factored in, people in the group who saw menu labels and recommended calorie guidelines consumed an average of 250 fewer calories than people in the other groups.

Unsurprisingly this result is being pitched as evidence in favor of mandatory calorie labeling and the headline used by credulous news sources like USA Today is quite a bit different from my own. Digging a bit deeper into the actual study [pdf] complicates the picture.

To its credit, the study addresses one of the questions ignored by much of the previous research: The possibility that people who are prompted to order lighter meals because they see calorie information will compensate by eating more food at other times. This study attempts to account for that by doing follow-up interviews with participants about what they consumed for the rest of the day. And this is where things get interesting:

Most striking was the impact of adding daily caloric requirement information to the menu. It was surprising how much participants in the calorie labels condition ate in the evening hours following the meal; when calories consumed in this condition during and after the study meal were combined, there was no advantage for calorie labeling only over no labeling. The advantage occurred when the menu included both calorie labels and a prominently displayed notice stating the average person should consume approximately 2000 calories per day. Total caloric intake for the combination of the study meal and food consumed later was 1630 calories, 1625 calories, and 1380 calories for the no calorie labels, calorie labels only, and calorie labels plus information conditions, respectively.

Emphasis mine. In other words, this study supports the arguments made by critics of mandatory labeling by finding that labeling alone doesn’t lead to reduced total consumption. Of course, that result is never mentioned in the press release.

There are other limitations to the study, perhaps most substantially the fact that it took place in an environment far removed from the atmosphere of a restaurant:

When participants arrived at 5:30 pm on the first day, they had been instructed to abstain from eating after 2:30 pm to standardize hunger levels. The experiment took place in a university classroom in a building not affiliated with eating research. Participants sat behind dividers so they could not see others’ meal choices; 2 to 14 individuals participated per study session.

It’s difficult to imagine anyone finding this environment conducive to having a pleasant meal. I have to wonder if outside a lab, when trying to enjoy themselves, participants would be more likely to indulge despite the calorie recommendation.

Regardless of that, this study suggests that calorie labeling alone won’t be sufficient to change diets. Thus we come to the next step:

The findings support the proposal that chain restaurants should be required to post calorie labels on restaurant menus; however, they suggest that to maximize the effectiveness of this policy, menu items should also include a label informing individuals of the daily caloric requirements for an average adult.

As Jacob Sullum wrote of mandated calorie postings last year, “There’s a difference between informing people and nagging them.” If health researchers get their way that difference is about to get even smaller.

Previously: For more on the question of whether nutritional information should be prominently posted or merely made available, see this post from July.

Comments

  1. bmack says:

    If I were eating a restaurant with prominent calorie information on the menu, I would order low-calorie dishes for the sole purpose of appearing not overindulgent. I would probably also focus on maintaining a modest number of calories, while ignoring the nutritional content of those calories. As always, pushing a single metric is no substitute for holistic nutritional education.

  2. Daniel says:

    I think it’s important to note, regarding the lack of difference in calories consumed between the calorie-labeled-only group and the non-labeled group, that it’s fairly common knowledge that, for weight loss, it’s best to spread your calories out during the day–the idea that, when dieting, you should have six meals per day, rather than three.

    So, even if there’s no ultimate difference in total calories consumed between the group that had only calorie labeling and the group that had no calorie labeling, putting calories on the menu still imbues a behavior that is ultimately helpful for the group that had calorie labeling. Losing weight isn’t just about the number of calories consumed–it’s also about how they’re consumed.

  3. Switching video heroes of dragon age cheats gaming towards addiction. Wii is considered one of the
    greatest issue for the prize that comes around.

  4. Thank you, I have just been looking for info approximately this subject for a while
    and yours is the best I have came upon till now.
    But, what concerning the conclusion? Are you positive in regards to the supply?

  5. wine stains says:

    This lightens blemishes by bleaching them and gradually causes them to blend with the natural skin color.
    The ‘Bourbon butter cookies’, to quote from the packet they
    came in, added to that short moment of enjoyment. Also, you are able to pick out
    age your prefer your wine to be.

  6. What was also really obsessed about this disease and
    many of medical science has advanced fully, and others. However, in fact has its most advanced type of breast cancer awareness promotional product
    as well, but I did a microarray analysis. Buck cited AHA statistics that show the
    same, Bernie S Siegel MD author of breast cancer awareness Your Personal Guide
    to Fighting Breast Cancer gallery and contribute to
    the gym, at least seven hours or less. Metastasis of
    Breast Cancer Alternative TreatmentFood is not necessarily mean it
    will not make lump detection impossible.

  7. Hello, its nice post concerning media print, we all be aware of media is a great source
    of information.

  8. What better way to support the old with all the zest in the new.
    The mentioned recreation titles are only some with the many racing game titles obtainable for Xbox 360 immediately and it’s nonetheless
    persevering with to grow. For his incredible victory series on the most important races for that three
    yr old season, Bernardini seemed to be awarded the Eclipse
    award for your Three Year Old Male. You can well think about the effects these games would create
    on budding minds. Indianapolis 500 Racing for the Wii puts you when driving of some legendary vehicles,
    to become driven at high-speed only. It’s pleasant strategy to
    spend a while by actively playing car games online. Fortunately
    for PC game players and collective racing fans, there’s still enough substitute for have some single player and online fun,
    get the job done genre isn’t at the forefront of a lot of companies
    minds. The solution to this problem is incredibly simple- live horse racing videos.
    Most with the games have very low system requirements when compared with some in the expensive high-end retail games that might be inside shops.
    The websites assure how the games are personally played and rated by the in-house professionals and also this ensures quality
    gaming. The games are getting to be more technical with all the increase inside the internet speed and
    better resolutions for 3D graphics. Project CARS is slated
    for any November 14 release around the Play – Station 4, Xbox One and PC.
    Finding an ideal parking spot may be a tricky job and a similar could be the case inside virtual world.
    These tips will get you a long way in Drag Racing but lose
    a considerable amount of their value if you choose an unacceptable car.

    This allows the less skilled person (your better half) to bar if she’s being overwhelmed, whilst you go ahead and save the
    day. The rigors to be a proficient race driver are likely to
    be also included (like having to deal using a car’s tire condition and fuel level).
    Where on one side we witness the comparatively shorter
    racing tenure to the new generation thoroughbreds, the horses from your centuries before this were stronger, sturdy and tolerant.
    The games provide you with the actual thrill and adrenalin rush you’d experience around the race tracks,
    due to its messaging board where the players get to
    share with you race statistics and discuss strategies along with
    other players and experts. Among the most popular
    Xbox racing and driving games, Grand Theft Auto Double Pack, Forza Motorsport, Need for Speed Most
    Wanted or Ralli – Sport Challenge 2 and also the legendary Simpsons Hit and
    Run falls within the common preference one of many players.

    In most cases the vehicle racing games is 2D (two dimensional) and 3D
    (3 dimensional) in characteristics and also this allows the
    gamer to perspective every aspect from the car
    while the levels of competition are in success.

    Hence, it’s may be beneficial in the event you conduct thorough online research.
    These usually are high quality games that take small parts in the movies with everyone’s cartoon characters to offer fun objectives or tasks to finish
    to win. Following his maiden break that ended away from money, Bernardini list of
    with a winning streak of six races made up of handpicked graded specials.
    Many online racing games permit you to select a vehicle you will use to race with players.

    You can increase your visions and understand processes for combating against evil forces.

  9. Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to protet against hackers?
    I’m kinda paranoid about losing everything I’ve worked hard on. Any tips?

  10. Google says:

    is updated frequently with free advice about Google Ad – Words
    strategy, tactics, tips tricks and techniques for success in Ad –
    Words advertising. These pre-computed numbers, hold on in a very giant information bank for millions or URLs on the net.

    Besides placing advertisers ads on your Blog, you can also make money Blogging by placing Google Adsense
    into your Blog.

  11. Philipp says:

    hello!,I love your writing so a lot! proportion we keep up a correspondence more about your article on AOL?
    I need an expert on this hhouse to unravel my problem. Maybe that’s
    you! Taking a look forward to see you.

  12. Hi my family member! I wish to say that this article is
    awesome, great written and come with almost all important infos.
    I’d like to see more posts like thus .

  13. Ubisoft, at a very short amount of convenience and unique, and have a babysitter, and what they thought it should clash of lords 2 hack
    be able to determine the best and most uninteresting days.

    They are able to rise to the list and make sure they are
    treated.

  14. Fastidious response in return of this matter with solid arguments
    and telling thhe whole thing concerning that.

  15. Jacinto says:

    Your article is definitely useful. More than that, it is engaging, compelling and well-written.
    I would desire to see even more of these types of good writing.

  16. It’s all too common, however, for many households to choose between groceries
    and prescription drugs when tey can’t afford both.

    With the articles available in the internet, explaining tthe real facts about the cheap generic drugs, people
    ave now started too bbuy generic drugs for common diseases.
    If youu are not feeling well then youu cant take it until you are
    well. If payment is by check or money order, make sure to specify the number and date of the instgrument in the receipt.
    Take Propechia under medical recommendation to
    guardd atainst possible side effects like impotence. HP
    has publicly vowed to crack down around the printer ink refills market.

  17. I was wondering if you ever thought of changing the structure of your website?
    Its very well written; I love what youve got to say.
    But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better.
    Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or 2 pictures.
    Maybe you could space it out better?

  18. web site says:

    Unquestionably believe that that you stated.
    Your favorite resason seemed to be at the net the simplest factor to take into account
    of. I say to you, I certainly get irked whilst ofher folks think about issues that
    thhey just ddo not undersrand about. You managed to hiit the nail
    upon the top and also outlined out the whole thing without having side effect , people could take a signal.
    Will probably be back to gget more. Thanks

  19. internet says:

    If you are going for best contents like I do, simply pay
    a quick visit this web page every day as it provides feature contents,
    thanks

  20. Gustavo says:

    If you want to change your IP address so you can unblock
    websites and access foreign websites, then use PPTP VPN.

    The next i – Phone accessory worth buying is undoubtedly a car
    or travel charger. Strip or Secure Tool for Recalling Important Passwords is another
    secure password manager and data vault that protects your sensitive information using 256-bit AES encryption.

  21. This is certainly a wonderful Bliitz Brigade cost-free hack device !

  22. Nan says:

    It’s great that you are getting thoughts from this article as well as from our dialogue made at
    this place.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] of such legislation found that customers were much more likely to head caloric warnings when recommended daily intake was also posted. Many states are now considering nutrition information laws and fast food chains [...]

  2. [...] Mangu-Ward | January 11, 2010 There are a lot of problems with requiring that restaurants include calorie counts on their menus and placards. But one of the [...]

  3. [...] are a lot of problems with requiring that restaurants include calorie counts on their menus and placards. But one of the [...]

Leave a Comment

*