Yale study finds calorie labeling doesn’t work

There’s a new study out about calorie labeling and it comes to some interesting conclusions. It’s from the Rudd Center at Yale, authored by Christina Roberto, Peter D. Larsen, Henry Agnew, Jenny Baik, and Kelly D. Brownell. Here’s the basic description of the methodology and conclusion from the Rudd Center’s release:

The researchers studied 303 adults in New Haven, Connecticut, dividing them into three groups – the first saw a menu with no calorie labels, the second saw a menu with calorie labels, and the third saw a menu with calorie labels plus information on the recommended daily caloric intake for an average adult.

Participants in the two groups who saw calorie labels ate 14 percent fewer calories than the group whose participants did not see calorie labels. Furthermore, when after-dinner eating was factored in, people in the group who saw menu labels and recommended calorie guidelines consumed an average of 250 fewer calories than people in the other groups.

Unsurprisingly this result is being pitched as evidence in favor of mandatory calorie labeling and the headline used by credulous news sources like USA Today is quite a bit different from my own. Digging a bit deeper into the actual study [pdf] complicates the picture.

To its credit, the study addresses one of the questions ignored by much of the previous research: The possibility that people who are prompted to order lighter meals because they see calorie information will compensate by eating more food at other times. This study attempts to account for that by doing follow-up interviews with participants about what they consumed for the rest of the day. And this is where things get interesting:

Most striking was the impact of adding daily caloric requirement information to the menu. It was surprising how much participants in the calorie labels condition ate in the evening hours following the meal; when calories consumed in this condition during and after the study meal were combined, there was no advantage for calorie labeling only over no labeling. The advantage occurred when the menu included both calorie labels and a prominently displayed notice stating the average person should consume approximately 2000 calories per day. Total caloric intake for the combination of the study meal and food consumed later was 1630 calories, 1625 calories, and 1380 calories for the no calorie labels, calorie labels only, and calorie labels plus information conditions, respectively.

Emphasis mine. In other words, this study supports the arguments made by critics of mandatory labeling by finding that labeling alone doesn’t lead to reduced total consumption. Of course, that result is never mentioned in the press release.

There are other limitations to the study, perhaps most substantially the fact that it took place in an environment far removed from the atmosphere of a restaurant:

When participants arrived at 5:30 pm on the first day, they had been instructed to abstain from eating after 2:30 pm to standardize hunger levels. The experiment took place in a university classroom in a building not affiliated with eating research. Participants sat behind dividers so they could not see others’ meal choices; 2 to 14 individuals participated per study session.

It’s difficult to imagine anyone finding this environment conducive to having a pleasant meal. I have to wonder if outside a lab, when trying to enjoy themselves, participants would be more likely to indulge despite the calorie recommendation.

Regardless of that, this study suggests that calorie labeling alone won’t be sufficient to change diets. Thus we come to the next step:

The findings support the proposal that chain restaurants should be required to post calorie labels on restaurant menus; however, they suggest that to maximize the effectiveness of this policy, menu items should also include a label informing individuals of the daily caloric requirements for an average adult.

As Jacob Sullum wrote of mandated calorie postings last year, “There’s a difference between informing people and nagging them.” If health researchers get their way that difference is about to get even smaller.

Previously: For more on the question of whether nutritional information should be prominently posted or merely made available, see this post from July.

Comments

  1. bmack says:

    If I were eating a restaurant with prominent calorie information on the menu, I would order low-calorie dishes for the sole purpose of appearing not overindulgent. I would probably also focus on maintaining a modest number of calories, while ignoring the nutritional content of those calories. As always, pushing a single metric is no substitute for holistic nutritional education.

  2. Daniel says:

    I think it’s important to note, regarding the lack of difference in calories consumed between the calorie-labeled-only group and the non-labeled group, that it’s fairly common knowledge that, for weight loss, it’s best to spread your calories out during the day–the idea that, when dieting, you should have six meals per day, rather than three.

    So, even if there’s no ultimate difference in total calories consumed between the group that had only calorie labeling and the group that had no calorie labeling, putting calories on the menu still imbues a behavior that is ultimately helpful for the group that had calorie labeling. Losing weight isn’t just about the number of calories consumed–it’s also about how they’re consumed.

  3. No greater impact on the area, however, was that created with the 1875 opening of the 4.
    5-mile section of the Appalachian National
    Scenic Trail. Currently the metro started flooring website electric
    central heat and air set up plan assembly division of more than 400,000 pillow meters.

  4. A talented 3D animator, armed with 3D modelling software such
    as Autodesk’s Maya or 3ds Max has the power to create some truly
    stunning visual effects. The 2013 version proved a major success
    for the franchise; Saints Row IV has earned revenue of a whopping USD 13 million, making it one of the best-selling video game franchises.

    It is long also, and if you don’t want to finish missions,
    the game would never end.

  5. Hi mates, its wonderful post regarding tutoringand completely explained, keep it up all the time.

  6. 1646 says:

    I know this site presents quality dependent posts and additional data, is there any
    other website which offers these information in quality?

  7. Sadie says:

    I am now not certain where you are getting your information, but good
    topic. I needs to spend a while studying much more
    or working out more. Thanks for fantastic information I used to be
    looking for this info for my mission.

  8. Its a time to be creative and give your child a unique experience they will remember for years.
    I had much more fun than a spider can while playing
    around with this guy. One that also has to fight his teenage urges to do what’s right.

  9. Bߋn ba j’en parlerai sur mon site internet personnel

  10. Your website will only show in the search results when those particular keywords are used.

    The covered range is simply endearing: Satsang, Silence & Concentration, Posture & Diet, Sleep, Service,
    Charity, Endeavor, Yoga, and Blessings & Love- all of which are essential to the seeking of truth.

    When it comes to selecting a topic, I’d recommend that you
    start off with ebooks that are in alignment with your
    interests.

  11. Еxcellent post, j’espère en parler plus tard avec des voisins

  12. xxx en hd says:

    Tiens ϳe ϲomptais justement fɑire un post identique au votre

  13. Ces articleѕ sont assurément attractifs

  14. vidéo hot says:

    Maǥnifique рost, encore une fois

  15. hello there and thank you for your information – I’ve definitely picked up something new from right here. I did however expertise a few technical points using this website, as I experienced to reload the site lots of times previous to I could get it to load properly. I had been wondering if your web host is OK? Not that I’m complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will sometimes affect your placement in google and can damage your high quality score if ads and marketing with Adwords. Well I am adding this RSS to my e-mail and can look out for a lot more of your respective interesting content. Ensure that you update this again soon..

  16. Dead Space says:

    You can jam coke cans on weapons to make homebrew silencers, or a
    kitchen knife to a rifle to make a working bayonet. Body packs are useful for a variety of skin treatments,
    ailments and allergies, helps achieve relaxation, and also acts as
    an antiseptic in minor cuts, wounds and burns. This can throw off the humidity and temperature
    level. The truth is, the whole subject of Mind Power is nothing more than scientific
    claims for the principle of physical energy-does that mean Mind Power is identical with the physical energy
    of science. There may be others to have your system at optimal flow rates.
    Keep your lawn dry by removing excessive snow pack.

    A bathroom furniture unit could possibly be the perfect strategy to the condition mainly because it will hide away
    all of your bathroom essentials. One of our editors got their hands on the game before
    I did and they had to stop after the first ten minutes
    because it was THAT intense (he literally had to hand the controller over to someone else to continue playing).
    Unfortunately should you prefer a great deal of storage space then a few of
    your living area will likely be engrossed in units.
    You might want to mark where your stove is really as well if replacing the ventilation is really a large deal.
    For any other cheapskates out there, especially ones
    who like the feeling of tensing up as you round a darkened corridor, Dead Space
    is the game for you and your local Slackers has
    it. Even though it is great to possess sufficient drawers for silverware and stirring
    spoons, you will need a location to maintain your other kitchen necessities like aluminum foil,
    rubber bands, pot holders and dish towels. Dead Space 3 is all set to
    be released next week on February 5th. Possessing
    a big hard drive is not just important but to have lot of
    RAM (Random Access Memory) is vital. A problem can be looked upon as a worry or as a challenge (at which
    point it is no longer really a problem). There are even gameshow games
    and car races, add a steering wheel to your Wii controller and you
    feel as if you are the real driver. Women feel like they need to protect the relationship that
    they’ve built and they may refuse their guy’s suggestion outright.
    In case you are having second opinion of more cabinets then think
    about just how much storage you want since you do not want to do too
    much of it. The remainder of the side walls can be covered by
    either absorption or diffusion panels, depending on the
    size and layout of the room and the kind of speakers you’re including in your home
    theater. Never allow standing water to remain in the bottom
    of the terrarium. Getting jumped all the time by enemies can get a little
    frustrating. For centuries Planet Earth has been in the far distant space of the Milky Way
    Galaxy, disconnected from the powerful Pulse of Creation in the Galactic Core.
    A mattress that sags down in the center is shot, no matter how many (or few) years you have had it.
    For example, you can get one made entirely of wood that features rich finishes or hand painted accents, even eloquent carvings.
    Many people have a garage but don’t use it, and it just gets used for storage space.

  17. webdesign says:

    e-Commerce websites bring the whole world to the merchants doorstep.
    Definitely when you wake up from the slumber, you
    can be sure that you will be lagging behind and getting on track
    would be a tall order. Social media is becoming the go to platform for modern Internet marketing and
    has seen huge growth in recent years.

  18. Your game will be much easier only with Second Earth.

  19. rossibeco says:

    рециклинг I want to express appreciation to the writer just for bailing me out of such a instance. Right after looking throughout the internet and getting thoughts which were not productive, I believed my life was done. Being alive without the solutions to the problems you have resolved by means of your good posting is a serious case, and ones that could have adversely damaged my entire career if I hadn’t discovered your blog. Your own personal natural talent and kindness in taking care of all areas was very useful. I don’t know what I would have done if I had not come across such a point like this. It’s possible to now relish my future. Thanks a lot very much for this impressive and result oriented help. I won’t hesitate to suggest your site to any person who would like guidelines about this matter.

  20. rossibeco says:

    Переработка пластмасс I wish to point out my appreciation for your generosity in support of persons that really need help on this important content. Your personal commitment to getting the solution around became astonishingly significant and have in most cases encouraged girls much like me to realize their pursuits. Your informative guidelines implies a lot to me and a whole lot more to my fellow workers. Thank you; from everyone of us.

  21. Euh êtеѕ vouus sûr de ce que vous affirmez ?

  22. Јe me permets d’écrire un ϲom dans le but de complimenter le webmaster

  23. Je prendѕ la peine d’écrire ce petit com simplement pour féliciter son auteur

  24. bonne salope says:

    Je vais finir dee voir tout çа dans la soirée

  25. Un pօste vraiment plein de superbes conseils

  26. Thanks for the good writeup. It if truth be told used to be a amusement account it.
    Look complicated to more added agreeable from you! However, how
    can we keep in touch?

  27. jeune mature says:

    Post supeг intéressant !!

  28. hi!,I like your writing very a lot! proportion we keep in touch more approximately your post on AOL? I require an expert in this space to resolve my problem. May be that’s you! Having a look forward to peer you.

  29. Good article! We are linking to this great content on our website. Keep up the great writing.

  30. adult toys says:

    Its actually a cool and helpful piece of info. I am glad that you shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

  31. A motivating discussion is worth comment. I think that you ought to publish more on this topic, it might not be a taboo subject but generally people don’t speak about such subjects. To the next! Kind regards!!

  32. Hi mates, pleasant article and good arguments commented at this place, I am actually enjoying
    by these.

  33. problèmes avec mon dernier Site et Je souhaitez trouver quelque chose de plus sécuritaire
    sécurisé . Avez-vous des solutions recommandations suggestions

  34. Even the Honda systems were not very successful for the same reason. Replacing a Toyota Camry oxygen sensor is a little more involved and
    requires the right tools as well as a way to lift the vehicle to accomplish the replacement.
    2 million vehicles as gas pedals became stuck under floor mats, resulting in sudden speeding
    up.

  35. As a leading Company, The Original PC Doctor provides best IT support solutions.
    Checking for Registry errors is highly recommended.
    It can be challenging to find qualified technician providing affordable services; however, with moderate research and web browsing, you will be able to find a suitable technician.

  36. Lizzie says:

    hello!,I like your writing so so much! percentage we keep in touch more about your article on AOL?

    I require a specialist on this space to solve my problem.
    May be that’s you! Looking forward to look you.

  37. Thanks for your personal marvelous posting! I actually enjoyed reading it, you might be a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and definitely will come back in the future. I want to encourage one to continue your great work, have a nice day!

  38. Aurora says:

    Really enjoyed this blog post, can you make it so I receive an email every time you write a new update?

  39. Aurora says:

    hi!,I love your writing very much! proportion we communicate extra approximately your article on AOL? I require an expert on this space to unravel my problem. May be that’s you! Taking a look ahead to see you.

  40. I think this is one of the so much important info for me. And i’m glad reading your article. However wanna remark on few common issues, The site taste is perfect, the articles is truly great : D. Just right task, cheers

  41. Click Link says:

    Your home is valueble for me. Thanks!

  42. Go here says:

    I like the helpful information you provide for your articles. I will bookmark your blog and check again right here frequently. I’m slightly sure I’ll learn plenty of new stuff proper here! Best of luck for the next!

Trackbacks

  1. […] of such legislation found that customers were much more likely to head caloric warnings when recommended daily intake was also posted. Many states are now considering nutrition information laws and fast food chains […]

  2. […] Mangu-Ward | January 11, 2010 There are a lot of problems with requiring that restaurants include calorie counts on their menus and placards. But one of the […]

  3. […] are a lot of problems with requiring that restaurants include calorie counts on their menus and placards. But one of the […]

Leave a Comment

*